Stock-based Compensation: 3 Basics to Focus on this Year

Stock-based compensation can transform your life when it’s managed wisely.

Indeed, if you’re a tech professional, then you likely know how receiving stock awards isn’t just a perk, it’s your gateway to building generational wealth and securing your family’s financial future for decades to come.

With that said, however, too many well-intentioned individuals choose to give their grants a cursory look when they’re hired or following their annual review and then do nothing with them.

And so, what happens?

Well, from missed opportunities to surprise tax bills and the potential for a complete loss of wealth, many individuals find themselves set up for a complete disappointment down the road.

Now, if you’re a recipient of stock-based compensation, then there’s no doubt that you’re grateful for your awards.

With that said, it’s crucial, now more than ever, to move beyond just appreciation for what you have, to taking action so you can protect your potential windfall.

Indeed, without a proactive approach, you might find yourself unprepared for the tax implications, dealing with uncertainty about managing vesting awards, or exposing yourself to unnecessary risks given your concentrated stock position.

Nevertheless, by understanding how to navigate your stock grants, knowing what to watch for when it comes to your taxes, and mitigating risks through prudent financial planning, you can confidently use your wealth to not just support your lifestyle now, but to lay the foundation for a legacy that spans generations to come.

Get Familiar with Your Grants

Alright, so you know you have equity awards but have never bothered to look into them.

Now what?

Well, if you just started receiving stock compensation as part of your pay package, you might just have one grant to consider.

But, if you’ve been in your career for a while, then you likely have numerous grants to deal with, and so, you’re likely feeling overwhelmed and not sure where to start.

Well, let’s keep this simple and start by just getting familiar with what you own.

Indeed, one of the first things to do to make the most out of your equity compensation in the coming year is to just take some time to review your existing and refresher grants.

Having this birds-eye view of what you own and what’s likely to vest in the year ahead will give you an idea of what you should focus on as you consider your awards.

So then, you can start your review process by logging into your company’s platform for managing your equity comp.

This could be Morgan Stanley at Work, or Shareworks or Carta for managing stock compensation, and the app is typically available through your employer’s benefits portal.

Now, the beauty of these tools is that they offer a one-stop destination for managing and tracking your stock holdings.

And, these platforms offer a streamlined and user-friendly interface to view the value of your GSUs and RSUs, allow you to exercise your stock options or sell your vested restricted stock when the time is right, and help you understand some of the tax implications, all in one place.

Now, if you’re not sure which app your company uses, you can simply reach out to your manager or HR team, and they’ll point you in the right direction.

Either way, once you’re logged in, look for the section where equity grants are listed. This should include all the grants awarded to you, such as stock options, restricted stock units (RSUs), or other forms of equity comp.

Here what you’ll want to do is to take some time to get familiar with what you have. And while you’re at it, evaluate whether you’re holding onto stock options or restricted stock, or even, if you have a combination of both.

And why is this information important?

Well, quite simply, having this information on hand will enable you to make better choices with your awards down the road.

And here again, you’ll likely find more than one grant if you’ve worked for the company long enough and they offer stock refreshers.

Now, as you review your grants, what you’ll want to do is pay close attention to your vesting schedule.

And why start with your vesting schedule?

Well, while it might be tempting to look at your total award amount and begin making plans for the money in the year ahead, the truth is that your award, whether we’re talking GSUs, RSUs, or stock options, vest, or are generally made available to you over a set period, which is typically a four-year vest, with a one year cliff.

Now, this vesting period can vary from company to company. For example, Google and Facebook have four-year vesting schedules, while Microsoft has either a four or five year vesting schedule.

That’s why it’s crucial to pay attention to what you’ve got.

Now, this vesting information is also important for a couple of reasons, so listen up.

First, when it comes to a cliff vest, knowing that you’ll receive only a portion of your award this year can help you set better expectations for available cash in the coming year. Indeed, as mentioned earlier, many grants are offered with four-year vest and a one-year cliff.

So then, what this cliff-part means is that you have to stay with your employer for one year from the grant date if you started less than a year ago, so pay extra close attention here if you’re planning a career move in the months ahead.

Now, if you’ve been at your company for longer than a couple of years, then another thing to consider as you’re reviewing your grants is that you’ll likely have to juggle multiple vesting schedules over the course of the year.

Now, while it may be tempting to let yourself become overwhelmed by all this information, it’s crucial to remember that your primary focus should be to understand the TIMING of your vesting schedule.

Here again, it’s vital to understand what the cliff looks like for your new grant or stock refresher and whether your equity will vest monthly or quarterly in the year ahead.

The next thing you’ll want to consider as you’re reviewing your grants is to evaluate the current and expected market price (or the fair market value for private firms) of your employer’s stock relative to your vesting schedule, so you can determine whether there are any actions you need to plan take.

For example, if you’re holding onto stock options and your company’s value is expected to rise, then you may want to consider exercising your options sooner rather than later to lower AMT risks and start the clock on long-term capital gains.

And, if you’re holding onto restricted stock and market volatility is picking up around the time that your grants are about to vest and you need the cash, then selling stock as it vests may also be a worthwhile consideration for you as well.

Finally, if you’re planning on changing jobs this year, reviewing your grants will help you understand what you own and what your options are for dealing with your grant after you decide to leave your current employer.

Either way, the key takeaway here is to start by understanding what you’ve got. Doing so will help you get ahead of any surprises and help you be better prepared to take necessary actions, like exercising your stock options or evaluating whether to sell or hold your vested company stock if we’re talking about RSUs or GSUs.

Pay Particular Attention to Your Taxes

Alright, so now that you have a basic understanding of what to look for as you evaluate your stock award, let’s talk about everyone’s favorite topic: taxes.

Now, as you start evaluating your equity grants at the beginning of the year, it’s crucial to focus on several key tax-related areas to ensure you’re making well-informed decisions.

And the first of which is to know what you own.

Now, you’ll typically nail down this point when you initially review your grants.

Nevertheless, understanding the type of equity you have, whether it’s stock options or RSUs, often determines how you’re taxed, and how you should prepare.

Taxation of ISOs

So then, if you have stock options, especially ISOs, exercise timing likely will play a crucial role when it comes to taxes.

How so?

Well, when it comes to exercising ISOs, you have either a qualifying or disqualifying disposition to consider.

And what does this mean?

Well, in terms of a qualifying disposition, you’re likely looking at potential tax benefits if you hold the shares for a specific period, but this also involves the risk of triggering the alternative minimum tax (AMT).

Now, a disqualifying disposition on the other hand typically happens when you exercise and sell your options, meaning you likely avoid AMT, but now you’re paying taxes at ordinary income rates.

So far, so good, right?

Now, let’s stop and talk about AMT for just a second because some individuals get nervous when they hear about AMT and do one of two things.

First, they search the internet for ways to avoid it, or two, their eyes gloss over, and they simply ignore their grant, hoping it all works out on its own in the end when they blindly pull the trigger.

Don’t be this person!

You know, when it comes down to it, AMT isn’t going to eat you alive!

(At least, not entirely!)

What is Alternative Minimum Tax

In fact, what you should know is that the AMT is a parallel tax system designed to ensure that individuals who benefit from certain tax advantages pay at least a minimum amount of tax.

In other words, Uncle Sam wants to ensure that if you make a lot of money, you’re not just using deductions and other tax loopholes to avoid paying taxes altogether.

And so, when you exercise ISOs and don’t sell the shares in the same year, the difference between the exercise price and the fair market value at the time of exercise is considered a “preference item” for AMT purposes.

This means it could increase your AMT liability, potentially leading to a higher tax bill.

So then, to effectively plan for AMT, you should calculate your potential AMT liability before exercising ISOs and carefully consider the timing of your ISO exercises and sales in the year ahead.

This could include exercising earlier in the year, giving you more visibility into the potential AMT impact, and allowing you to make adjustments later in the year if needed.

You could also consider exercising ISOs in smaller amounts over several years to help manage AMT exposure.

How are RSUs Taxed

Now, when it comes to taxation of GSUs or RSUs, the story here is a little simpler but still nuanced nonetheless.

Indeed, there’s often a misconception that GSUs and RSUs are “double-taxed,” which can be somewhat misleading, so let’s clarify how taxation works here and why your vesting schedule is so important.

To start, you’re taxed on your restricted stock when it vests, not when you receive your award.

And when RSUs vest, the value of the shares at that point is considered taxable income. And this gain is taxed at ordinary income tax rates, just like your salary.

This is what many would consider the first tax event.

Here again, you don’t get taxed the full amount of the grant when it’s awarded to you. In fact, you typically get taxed as your award vests throughout the course of the year, and this is another reason why it’s so crucial to understand your vesting schedule before you do anything else.

And so, how much tax will you pay?

Well, the amount of income recognized is equal to the market value of the shares on the vesting date, not the grant date.

Now, when it comes to paying these taxes, your employer will typically handle the tax by withholding a portion of the vested shares. In many cases, the default withholding amount is too low and so you can either change the withholding or set aside extra cash to pay tax as your awards vest.

Now, if you decide to sell your shares immediately as they vest, then you likely won’t have any other taxes to deal with.

In other words, you’re only taxed once.

With that said, however, the second taxable event here takes place when you decide to hold onto those shares and sell them at some point in the future.

In this case, you’re dealing with capital gains tax if the shares have increased in value from the vesting date. More specifically, that capital gains is calculated from the vesting date, and not the grant date, so pay careful attention to that information.

That’s why, if you sell the shares right after they vest, the capital gains tax is often minimal since there’s little or no gains to report. However, if you hold onto your vested shares and they appreciate in value, then you’re likely looking at capital gains tax when you go to sell that stock later on down the road.

So, you’re taxed at ordinary income at vest, and pay capital gains tax if you hold your vested stock and later sell your appreciated holdings.

At the same time, knowing your vesting dates allows you to plan for taxes more strategically.

For example, if you know that you’ve got a large number of GSUs vesting this year, then you might adjust other financial decisions, like managing gains recognition or charitable giving, so you can manage your overall tax liability more effectively.

At the same time, your strategy for selling the vested shares can significantly impact your capital gains tax. That’s because holding onto the shares for more than a year after they vest could qualify any gains for the lower long-term capital gains tax rate.

So then, while GSUs and RSUs are not exactly “double-taxed” in the traditional sense, they do involve two distinct tax considerations: the income tax at the point of vesting and the capital gains tax upon selling the shares.

Turn Concentration Risks into Strategic Financial Player

Alright, so we’ve talked about what to consider as you evaluate your grants, including knowing what you own, your vesting schedule, and potential tax implications to keep in mind.

But what do you do after your awards vest?

In other words, how do you turn this seeming windfall into a strategic power player in your overall financial plan?

Well, the truth is that for many of you out there, there’s often a temptation to just “let it ride” when it comes to the company stock you now own.

And while the default “do nothing” approach may seem appealing at first, you could be setting yourself up for disappointment if you’re not staying on top of the opportunities and, more crucially, avoiding key threats to your wealth like concentration risk.

And what is concentration risk?

Well, concentration risk means that you’re potentially putting yourself in a financially vulnerable position when a large portion of your wealth is tied up in the equity of a single company like your employer’s stock.

And why is this important?

Well, when you’re not actively engaging and staying informed about your equity grants, you may inadvertently find yourself in a position where your financial well-being is heavily dependent on the performance of your company’s stock.

Now, this can be a risky position to be in because your financial fate is often tied to the fortunes of just one company.

So then, if your employer faces a sudden surprise like a lawsuit, changes in legislation, market volatility, or sector-specific declines, then your personal net worth could take a significant hit along with these adverse situations.

At the same time, the danger here is twofold.

That’s because your job security is linked to the company’s performance, and, more often than not, so is your investment.

And so, if your employer encounters difficulties of different stripes, not only is your job potentially on the line, but your investments in the company (and your net worth) might be on the hook as well.

And so, this dual exposure can have a more profound impact than if your investments were diversified across different sectors or asset classes.

At the same time, you might miss opportunities to diversify your investments by not actively managing your grants.

Now, we’ve often talked about how diversification is a key principle to sound financial planning and risk management.

That’s because it involves spreading your investments across various asset classes or sectors to reduce the chance of financial loss.

So then, if a significant portion of your wealth is held in vested stock that you haven’t gotten around to dealing with, then you might be setting yourself up for a disappointment should one “black swan” or unexpected event come along.

That’s why, here again, as you look at your grants, consider how they fit into your broader investment portfolio.

Then, consider your holdings and evaluate whether you’re dealing with any imbalances by heavily concentrating your wealth in one position or one sector.

If that’s the case, then it might be time to think about strategies like selling a portion of your vested shares and investing the proceeds in a diversified basket of assets. This approach not only helps mitigate risks, it also potentially enhances the growth of your investments through opportunities in different sectors or geographic regions of the markets.

The point here is that while stock awards can be a lucrative part of your compensation, they should be managed as part of a broader, diversified investment strategy to minimize risks and maximize potential gains.

It’s not about how much you make but how much you keep, right?

That’s why, as your shares vest, think about selling portions of them at regular intervals and then using the proceeds from these sales to purchase other investments that align with your financial goals, whether that’s buying a home, saving for retirement, or investing in a diversified portfolio of stocks, bonds, or other assets.

Stock-based Compensation: 3 Basics to Focus on this Year

You know, when it comes down to it, your stock compensation is not just a significant part of your income, it’s also a reflection of your hard work and is a crucial means for quickly achieving financial independence and building generational wealth.

Even so, this opportunity also comes with the responsibility of proactively managing a vital component of your current and future net worth.

That’s why when you familiarize yourself with your grants, understand the nuanced tax implications, and turn concentration risks into strategic financial plays, each step acts as a building block toward securing your financial future and laying the groundwork for wealth that lasts beyond your lifetime.

Indeed, by avoiding the common pitfalls of ignoring your grants, being caught off guard by taxes, or failing to diversify post-vest, you’re not just positioning yourself to make smart, informed decisions that align with your life priorities, family values, and long-term goals, you’re taking one step closer to becoming the master of your own financial independence journey.

Privacy Preference Center

Discover more from Franklin Madison Advisors - Private Wealth Management

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading